top of page

What If Shaquille O’Neal Never Left The Orlando Magic?

Updated: 2 days ago

What if Shaq never left Orlando?

With free agency looming in the summer of 1996, the air crackled with nervous anticipation throughout the Sunshine State, specifically in Orlando where Shaquille O'Neal, the unstoppable force, the Disney World of a human being, was a coveted prize. Penny Hardaway, his electrifying backcourt partner, had already signed an extension, a beacon of hope for Magic fans. Yet, whispers of Los Angeles, of Kobe Bryant, a young talent with a killer instinct, swirled around Shaq.

However, rather than heading west to Hollywood, Penny's loyalty, his love for Orlando, and the potential for greatness, a modern-day version of Kareem (Abdul-Jabbar) and Magic (Johnson) resonated with Shaq. He saw the raw talent on the roster, the pieces forming a championship puzzle. He inked a historic deal, a commitment to build a dynasty with the Orlando Magic. 

The NBA landscape changed instantly. The Lakers, robbed of their dream pairing, scrambled. The Eastern Conference trembled. Orlando, with a Shaq-Penny duo hungrier than ever, became a juggernaut.

The next two seasons would become a masterclass in dominance. Shaq, fueled by a desire to prove his loyalty wasn't a mistake, became a physical marvel. His dunks were highlight-reel material, his post moves were unstoppable. Penny, thriving alongside his best friend, weaved magic with the ball, a scoring machine complementing Shaq's brute force.

The supporting cast wasn't shabby either. Dennis Scott, a human flamethrower, rained threes. Nick Anderson, overcame his nightmare from the championship series against the Houston Rockets to once again become a 3 and D (defense) terror. Coach Brian Hill cultivated a culture of hard work and brotherhood.

The 1997 NBA Playoffs arrived. The Chicago Bulls, a dynasty nearing its end, stood as the final hurdle. Michael Jordan, ever the competitor, relished the challenge. The series was a war of attrition. Jordan, fueled by a personal vendetta against Shaq who'd dared to challenge his “Airness” as the face of the league, went supernova. But Shaq was a force of nature. Penny, with ice water in his veins, hit clutch shots. The Magic, in seven grueling games, dethroned the Bulls in the Eastern Conference Finals, sending shockwaves through the league. 

Shaq and Penny - Dynamic Duo

Representing the Western Conference in the NBA Finals would be the Utah Jazz, winners of a franchise-best 64 games. Led by MVP Karl Malone and his future Hall-of-Fame teammate John Stockton, the veteran Jazz team managed to take two games against the Magic in the best-of-seven series before the championship confetti rained down in Amway Arena.

The city of Orlando was jubilant. A parade would soon engulf the city streets, a championship banner to be raised in the rafters – it was a moment etched in history. Shaq, standing 7’1”, 300lbs grinned from ear to ear as he danced at halfcourt before hoisting the Larry O’Brien trophy – a testament to his gamble, his loyalty. The core remained intact, hungry for more.

The next two years were a showcase of Magic dominance. The Eastern Conference finals became an annual tradition. The Knicks, the Pacers, the Bulls, none could withstand the Shaq and Penny juggernaut. In 1999, with two titles already in hand, they faced a new challenge: the young San Antonio Spurs, led by a stoic Tim Duncan. The series was historic – a clash of titans, a new rivalry brewing. In seven epic games, the Spurs prevailed, but respect was earned.

The turn of the millennium brought change. Penny, plagued by injuries, wasn't the same explosive player. The front office, desperate to maintain their window, made a risky trade, sending Penny to Detroit for a young Grant Hill. The gamble backfired. Hill, talented but injury-prone himself, was never the same player as what he was expected to be coming into the league several years earlier. 

Shaq, however, remained a constant. He adapted his game, becoming a more well-rounded scorer. He mentored younger teammates like Mike Miller, and Ron Mercer, fostering a new generation of Magic talent.

The dynasty sputtered, but never fully died. Orlando remained a playoff contender for the next five years. Shaq, with his sheer size and determination, remained a force, eventually moving to the West Coast to join the Lakers in 2005. Although he would help a young LA superstar win a pair of titles, Shaq was forever a Magic legend, becoming the first Orlando player to have his number 32 jersey hanging proudly in the rafters.

His legacy? A dynasty built on loyalty, two championship banners would forever change Orlando. He left the Magic a better franchise than he found it, a mentor who shaped future generations. He proved that greatness wasn't just about individual accolades, but about building something special, a homegrown dynasty in the heart of Florida.

Shaq never forgot his promise. He remained a fixture in Orlando, a businessman, an ambassador for the city, and the team that gave him his start. The "What If" of Los Angeles faded, replaced by the enduring legacy of Shaq, the Magic Man, forever a champion in the Sunshine State.

9 views0 comments


bottom of page